The Good Wife is so good, it can do the sort of stunt casting that makes most other shows look as though they’re begging for viewers and pull it off with whatever passes for integrity in the world of law firms. By which I mean, if you had no idea that guest star Miranda Cosgrove, playing a Disney Channel teenybop idol, was a Nickelodeon teenybop idol (iCarly), you probably just thought this young woman was a good actress in a clever plot.
Cosgrove’s Sloan Burchfield was an actress-singer trying to “climb out of the Disney ghetto thing.” To make her image hipper, Sloan went to a nightclub, drank too much, and subsequently was accused of hitting a car, injuring a woman, and found herself on trial for attempted murder. Alicia’s firm defended her.
As always, the series layered in small details that gave the story an authoritative air. Having Alicia’s daughter, Grace, read Paris (Perez?) Hilton’s tweets about Sloan’s courtroom underwear was a nice touch, as was the portrayal of Sloan’s mom (played by the fine New York stage actress Laila Robins) as a shrewd variation on a Dina Lohan-ish stage mother.
As always, there were at least two equally important subplots to this hour. In the first, Chris Noth’s Peter, by way of his campaign manager Eli (Alan Cumming), sought the endorsement of his spiritual adviser, Pastor Isaiah. In the second, an arrogant member of Alicia’s law firm — Zach Grenier’s David Lee — unsettled Michael Ealy’s Derrick Bond sufficiently that he’s decided Lee and Christine Baranski’s Diane are plotting against him. (Indeed, they seem to be.) I wasn’t quite clear how David Lee became such a powerhouse in the law firm (I know, they said he pulls in a lot of money, but that guy was really rude to Bond), but I’m willing to see how this power play plays out.
The episode was studded with terrific actors. David Paymer reappeared as a huffy judge, and Frankie Faison exerted his effortless authority as the Reverend Isaiah’s father. Anika Noni Rose continued her guest arc as Peter’s political rival, with her Wendy Scott-Carr trying to steal Eli from Peter.
When the hour ended, my mind circled back to the opening scene, in which Alicia is given the results of her peer review and is found by some in the office to be “standoffish.” I like the way The Good Wife plays with the way Julianna Margulies can seem reserved when she chooses to do so. More unusual was the way Alicia reacted to the information. Rather than toss off the criticism as mere backbiting, she asked the creepy David Lee to put in a good word for her. Why? Because the new peer-review method, as unfair as it may be, is tied to her future compensation, and Alicia has decided she both wants and needs her job.
Once again, by grounding itself in the tough reality of the workplace, The Good Wife ended up revealing much about its human characters.
Did you watch?
Twitter: @kentucker









As usual, the best hour of non-cable tv right now!
I’ll drink (my coffee) to that! I liked the nice touches of Sloan being envious of Alicia and her relationship with her daughter. It added a lot of authenticity. It was kind of a low key story, but still better than any other show on TV right now.
Miranda Cosgrove was pretty good, and she is the weak link on iCarly, more people should give it a chance, its one of the best shows on tv, Jerry Trainor is hilarious and Jennette McCurdy is the true star of the show, it is a kids show, but the humor is broad
I find Jerry Trainor too much of a Jim Carrey wannabe on iCarly. I’d rather give him a chance in something else.
@KC – Jim Carrey wannabe?
I wholeheartedly disagree, the man is absolutely hilarious, and Jim Carrey did not invent physical comedy nor was he the best at it, Jerry Trainor is a special talent all his own, and it hopefully will only be a matter of time before his star rises
Miranda was very good. She’s better at drama than comedy because she’s the weakest thing about iCarly. But since I can’t picture as anything but Carly, I kept waiting for the prosecution to bring out Nevel as their star witness.
i’ll drink (my tea) to that too! its amazing how much a semingly bland case can by saved by good writing and great acting. GW really is the best non cable show out there. (with Vamp Diaries close behind)
Wasn’t that PEREZ Hilton’s tweets?
it was paris
Yeah I think that may have been a mistake that the writers made or something…I don’t see why Paris Hilton would be tweeting about a Disney actress, it’s definitely a Perez Hilton thing to do.
They probably didn’t want to give Perez a shout out but Paris is no better.
This show is so good! Miranda Cosgrove was outrageously good and Anika Noni Rose character is such a B-tch! Hope she gets hers in the end.
Seddie…
I know this is a bit off-topic, but I just wanted to agree that Jennette McCurdy has tons more natural comic acting talent than Miranda Cosgrove. I hope to see McCurdy on a prime time sitcom someday. She deserves it.
I’m pretty sure Perez Hilton has copyrighted his name or something, so they probably wouldn’t be able to use it. The writers made it more confusing since there is actually a Paris Hilton, but maybe they figured we all forgot she exists.
Alicia did say Paris Hilton but thought she really ment Perez. Why would Paris be tweeting that kind of gossip. More of a Perez thing.
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Thank you for your expert commentary. It is greatly appreciated.
Yes, we appreciate the time you took and the effort you made to articulate your views so expertly. I’ve always looked to you as a role model.
Oooh! I’ve got it!
Frank Wright has drawn a picture of a ladder lying on the ground.
It symbolizes that no matter how fast and how hard Alicia tries to climb, she never gets off the ground. What an astute and subtle observation, Mr Wright. I look forward to your insights in future talkbacks.
lmao!!!! very very funny.
Frankly, sir, you are just so right. Your post was such a striking icon of intellectual architecture, I have to wonder why you left out the “Lloyd.”
Nice to see Kalinda back in form again. Go, K!
Also loved Diane rolling her eyes at the sports talk from her 2 partners. Been there, rolled that. But why is Will going along with Bond so often? What’s the underlying story there? I hope that comes out soon.
OTOH, I knew the sister was the really guilty one from the moment the client said, “Don’t put her on the stand.” They need to make that less obvious.
Oh, see I didn’t take the “Don’t put her on the stand” to be foreshadowing at all. I figured that since Sloan said she didn’t remember what happened, she thought anything her sister said on the stand would be a lie told to protect her and that she didn’t want her sister caught lying under oath. I only started to realize the sister did it at the same time Kalinda did, when the sister was on the stand and talking about the car hitting the wall and making sparks.
my thoughts exactly……
“Been there, rolled that.”
Let me preface this by saying I’m a man who watches few sports I don’t actually, y’know, PLAY…. or worse, read the bloody paper about them. I’m from Pittsburg, actually do enjoy pro football and still went skiing during two ‘burg superbowls.
Nonetheless, be VERY careful what you wish for.
You might think you want a guy who isn’t always reading/watching/playing sports or tinkering in the garage or playing computer games or whatever, but heed this:
e (on average) think differently than you, and that is a good thing.
In other words, do you *really* want a boyfriend/husband into feminine stuff?
If the answer is no, then cut us some slack. We love you. A lot. But we SO don’t want to be interrupted when we are in “manspace” (and here I’m talking much more about playing sports/building-designing stuff/working on projects than watching some random boring baseball game.)
And we could *really* do without the eye-rolling. I could list a reciprocal eyerolls, but this post is about love and reality, not keepin’ score.
*Pittsburgh
*we (on average) think differently…
Man this site needs an edit feature…
This show gets better and better. All last night’s storylines were great. Laila Robins specializes in playing evil roles. A good story for Alicia’s daughter, too. And
leave it to Kalinda to figure it out.
I remember Laila Robins playing Diana, Jack McCoy’s former associate (and lover) on an episode of Law & Order. She’s a really good actress!
I recognized her immediately as Steve Martin’s wife in Planes Trains & Automobiles!
I’ve been watching The Good Wife since Day 1,faithfully. I really enjoy it- it’s good to see Alicia getting ahead in her career path.I think its all the subtle nuances of the many secondary characters that give this show its edge.I really like Cary Argos,of course,Kalinda, and the wonderful Eli Gold.I’m kind of excited to see how Alicia will handle Peter’s news that he intends to re-enter the work field, make really good money, so she won’t “have to work” as she’s been doing ever since he was imprisoned.Should play out well.
Peter didn’t take the job. So unless he wins the election, Alicia is still the only breadwinner.
The show does have a couple of loopholes related to Alicia’s job:
1. They win unrealistically often, and as often as not, because of a last second twist involving a surprise suspect who pops up at the last minute because of some aspect of their defense; and
2. They went to some effort to show us last season that Alicia was one of many minor associates at the firm, but she’s always involved in the big cases this season. They do explain it sometimes that she’s included because of her notoriety, but it’s almost as if she’s a partner.
Tiny nitpicks, though. I love the show, and am amazed how densely plotted it is.
The firm may have more wins than seems realistic, but so do the prosecutors on Law & Order, and for the very good reason that when it comes to entertainment, the audience likes the protagonist to come out on top MOST of the time. In last night’s episode, though, I really think the defense would have lost except that the sister decided to come forward and confess. As for Alicia’s presence on cases, some higher-up associates may have left as part of the firm’s budget crunch, and we don’t always know how big Alicia’s cases are compared to other unseen cases the firm might be handling. (It seems like a couple times she’s been sent to take care of “run-of-the-mill” cases that suddenly become more complicated. I don’t see Alicia’s presence as unrealistically jarring.
Having worked at a law firm similar to Alicia’s, I think she is doing the same kind of work as most talented mid-level associates. Technically, she’s a jr. associate (2nd year at the firm), but I imagine she’d had some legal experience before staying at home, and given that and her connections, they are having her do mid-level associate work — she’s got more knowledge than someone a year or two out of law school. That’s not unusual when someone comes back to law after a hiatus.
Of course, none of them would be in court that often — they’d be slogging through briefs and discovery back in the office — but that’s boring, and courtroom antics are dramatic. So yes, they’re stretching the truth (they also dress a lot better than most lawyers, lol) but that’s TV. BTW, I love the show.
i loved that the writers hinted at a future discourse between the two with just that one exchange. you can bet alicia wants to work regardless of her financial situation and since peter doesnt understand that, she’ll move one more step closer to Will
See, I got a very different vibe from that conversation. Peter is taking a huge risk, not just politically, but monetarily in continuing in the race. Alicia encourages him to stay in the race and not take some lucrative easy job that would make both of their lives easier. The reason, if though Alicia has issues with her husband Peter, she definitely supports the candidate Peter and what he believes in (further evidenced by her brother previously figuring out she wrote one of Peter’s campaign speeches).
I get an even differenter vibe.
Will = Sports Night.
Peter = [barf] Sex in the City*
Therefore Will must win at ALL costs.
*[barf] limited to season 3+ and, God Should He Exist Help Us Every One, the movies.
Now, i’m going to start watching “The Good Wife!” LOL I loved the “disney ghetto quote!”
It was excellent. I was happy to see a weekly case story decided on the show without just another Alicia-LGB “win of the week”. Loved Cary’s facial expressions of amusement and frustration. As good as the case was the subplots were even better. Office politics played to perfection and all the city politics crooked in every way. It was simply great. The best hour of drama on television. How did we viewers get so lucky.
The Good Wife is shockingly good, shockingly tasteful, especially for CBS, but clearly you haven’t seen Terriers (or Mad Men or Breaking Bad.)
@minister — I miss Terriers…<>
I consider myself a fan of Anika Noni Rose, but she is driving me crazy with her delivery on this show. Eli Gold should have kept his mouth shut. Anyway I am loving the twists and turns of the Good Wife. From politics to office politics and home issues. Wonderful! I’ve been trying to get everybody I know to watch this show.
Agree that Eli should’ve kept his mouth shut. As soon as he told Scott-Carr that they had the Pastor’s support, she must have made some phone calls. She was trying to hard in the meeting with the Pastor and she played the race card which the young pastor didn’t like…..Politics over religion like he said. So now what? Is the old man in charge of the church again and he’s going to endorse Wendy because of race?
Race Card? No way…good old-fashioned tribalism at work, see ethnic political machines at work…currently on display (between the Irish, Italians, Blacks, and Germans) in the Excellent “Boardwalk Empire.” Along with increasingly disturbing amount of influences churches (of all colors) have on our political system. Yeah, going with the sexually tarnished Irish Presbyterian guy simply didn’t make ruthless political sense. Not over the angelic black woman in an interracial marriage and cancer survivor with a pitch perfect singing voice. This is Chicago politics, baby! Darn it, I want to run for office just so Eli can be my campaign manager!
Spot on k8dee! I’m so glad they’re addressing this issue as part of the election campaign. It’s extremely current and relevant to what’s happening just now.
Good show. Now, I hate to be off-topic again, but I’m not sure where else to post this–Terriers is probably the best show on TV right now but nobody’s watching & it will probably get cancelled. Ken, is it possible you don’t like it? It seems to be totally up your ally, but you haven’t written word one about it. In fact, EW hasn’t. Some mainstream attention from EW would do wonders to help this great show.
Please! Write something! There’s so much dreck on TV & Terriers is awesome! HELP!!
I agree, Terriers is an awesome show with great story lines and superb actors. Please if nobody has seen this show check it out.
Yes, off topic but absolutely correct. Terriers is a great show and deserves to be a big hit.
Thank you! I was just thinking about how good “Terriers” is this morning!
Indeed. If Terriers becomes Firefly (via Elmore Leonard and Veronica Mars), I will salt my coffee with sad sad tears.
Another good episode from one of the best shows on TV. I’m glad Blake?, Kalinda’s cohort, wasn’t in this ep. He either can’t act or his character is dull.
I noticed this too and was rather glad about his absence.
Blake is so evil – I wonder how far they’ll let that go.
truly enjoy this show and last night’s episode was excellent – plots, sub-plots on every level. Great show – like Chuck & Castle (my 3 faves)!!!
I wasn’t sure about this episode at first…Miranda Cosgrove casting, though I’m not that familiar with her, seemed gimmicky. But she did a good job. Diana/David are plotting and I’m not sure why, I don’t want her to leave the law firm. Great episode as always…look forward to next week
Agreed, definitely do not want Diana to leave. I love Christine Baranski and don’t think the show would be the same without her sophisticated presence.
I think the Dianne/David scheming is designed to push Bond into revealing his intentions. It’s something I suggested last week when we learned Bond defended Blake in his trial for working for a gang. And last night’s revelation about Bond wanting to link his DC practice with the Chicago one, and wanting to buy out Dianne. Bond may be the equivalent of a mob lawyer…
Bonad an equivalent of a mob lawyer? That’s a good. Reading your comment now I’m starting to look at Bond in a different way. I never trusted him. I think his peer review is a way of getting rid of associates and not giving them the pay raises they deserve.
It was, as always, an excellent show. As a lawyer, I can say that the only way David Lee could get away with his attitude towards Bond was if he had back-up from Christine. No matter what squabbles partners get into, they always close ranks against an associate who doesn’t respect another partner’s authority and position. It’s also the quickest way for such an associate to never make partner at the firm, not to mention be out on their keester altogether.
I thought Lee was a partner, with an extremely lucrative (and portable) book of business. Is he really only an associate? That doesn’t make sense…
They mentioned his “Family Law Division” bringing so much money and he said none of “his” people better be peer reviewed.
Love the show when it focuses on cases at the firm and on the political race. Dont’ love it so much when it focuses on peoples’ love lifes.
I am more concerned with Alicia leaving her husband for Will than the political race, but all the subplots are so good. There has been
hints about the relationship yet.