'Flight of the Conchords' and 'Eastbound & Down': Which ended funnier?

Conchordseastbound_l
The ratings are in for the season-enders of the HBO Sunday-night comedies Flight of the Conchords and Eastbound & Down, and I’m a little surprised and mighty pleased to see that underdog Eastbound scored the higher ratings (904,000 vs. 678,000). Don’t get me wrong: I admire the droll musical-comics Bret and Jemaine, but I did think this season of Conchords was a bit off. The songs weren’t quite up to last season’s quality, and the plotlines were a tad more predictable.

On the other hand, Eastbound & Down finished with a strong surge of quality. Danny McBride’s down-and-out baseball pitcher Kenny Powers was (ugh, do I really have to write this?: SPOILER ALERT!) called up by the majors again… or so he thought. For a comedy as assiduously profane as Eastbound is, it’s also got a lotta heart. I was genuinely moved when Kenny found out his regained dream was smashed once again, and yet he had to go through the Kenny Powers-patented motions of leaving town in a roar of bravado. I was even more moved by the sad face of April (the wondrous Katy Mixon) when Kenny left her and her suitcase in the dust as he fled from a convenience store in his car.

Last season, Conchords still seemed like a breath of fresh air with its low-key, very welcome gentle humor, and it gained a lot of hip pop-culture cachet. But Eastbound & Down, conceived as nobody’s idea of “cool,” ended up showing us that vulgar comedy can still do lots of sutble things, and few things on TV so far this year have matched McBride’s portrait of a working-class guy trying to make it after imploding.

How about you? Did you watch either of these shows? Do you like the contrasting comedy styles of Conchords and Eastbound, or do you have a clear favorite?

Tags:

Comments (43 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3
  • Go Kenny Powers!

    Eastbound was hilarious and sooooo crude at the same time. I was completely grossed out and fascinated at the same time by so many things (the eyeball was just genious). Several times I actually found the show tugging at my emotions only to have some raunchy “oh my god, did he really say that” quickly follow. I really think that I liked the show and am curious and anxious to see what happens next if theybring it back.

  • Skorp

    I think FotC traded places about halfway through the season with Eastbound. Eastbound got better while FotC started to fall off. But either way, I’ve been a fan of the Conchords and I am now a fan of Kenny Powers. Hope to see them both return.

  • Dustin

    “Eastbound and Down is the greatest telvision show in the history of television in the world”- Ron Benningtion, Ron and Fez noon to three

  • bmath

    Katy Mixon – body double?

  • Tindalos

    EB&D was a breath of fresh air in the already stale landscape that defines
    ‘white-trash’ dramedy…
    We can only hope that HBO and their overlords realize they have a potential Trailer Park Boys – American
    Style on their hands – “I’m Goin’ Down”…

  • JB

    Eastbound & Down was solid last night. Capped off a quality season. My only complaint about the show was actually Will Ferrell. I love Ferrell and will watch pretty much anything he’s in, but his brand of humor just didn’t fit in on the show all that much.

  • Jackie

    Love both shows! Can’t wait for the next seasons!

  • kentucky girl

    I LOVED Flight of the Conchords last season but have only gotten a few chuckles out of Season 2. I didn’t find any of the songs very catchy and only a few of the storylines worked for me. I hope the boys come back stronger in Season 3

  • Nicole Cassandra

    I haven’t seen Eastbound yet but I have to disagree about FoC season being worst than the first. I think both of them were brilliant. Season one had more interesting plots cause they had to write them around already existing songs. So season 2 might be more predictable because it was the other way round but the songs were still super catchy. I think that’s what I like most about them, that at the end of the day they’re brilliant lyrics-songwriters.

  • Mary

    I absolutely loved this show & felt the same as others that it was touching & shocking at the same time. They better bring it back!!!!

  • Scott

    “Katy Mixon – body double?”
    Yep, it was a body double.
    Loved East Bound and Down and hope it comes back.

  • JB

    Thought EB & D was hilarious, and all I have to say about Katy Mixon is “they may not be real, but they were SPECTACULAR!!”

  • sil

    The second season of FOTC was awesome same or better than the first, but the season finale was sorta blah.. Don’t judge the whole season the finale. I love Flight and hope they come back for season 3. Eastbound is already my second favorite show and is funny as hell. Bring it on! there is room for all kinds of funny

  • Kent

    Please tell me that there will be a second season of Eastbound and Down, 6 episodes was far from enough!

  • Mr.Cee

    I must admit as much as I love FOTC, I was not as impressed with season 2 as I was with 1. FOTC seemed flat this year. The guys (Jemaine & Brett) just did not appear to be that into it as they were last year. They seemed a little “mechanical” in their parts.

Page: 1 2 3
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in TV

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP